RallyVerdict

Review roundup · Pickleball · US prices

Selkirk OMNI: what 8 testers say

Eight hands-on testers on the $300 Selkirk OMNI, a toned-down Boomstik: all found it less powerful, seven easier to control; half think $300 is a stretch.

By 9 min readUpdated

Selkirk OMNI

Shape
Elongated (16.5 in) or widebody (15.95 in)
Weight
7.9–8.2 oz listed, with removable weights
Thickness
16mm
Swingweight
118 ± 2 (elongated) and 112 ± 2 (widebody) listed; testers measured 117.5–122
Level
Intermediate to advanced
Price
$300

Retailer links are coming soon.

What 8 hands-on testers said
  • Less power and pop than the Boomstik
    8/8
  • The removable weights are a welcome feature
    8/8
  • Easier soft game than the BoomstikPickleball Studio found little difference with the weights on
    7/8
  • Still a powerful paddle, not a soft control paddle
    6/8
  • Good spin, but not class-leading
    6/8
  • Smaller sweet spot than the BoomstikOf those who compared directly; Pickleball Playbook found it bigger
    3/4
  • An edge guard came looseJohnkew and Matt's Pickleball
    2/8
Worth $300?
  • 4 a stretch
  • 2 yes
  • 2 didn't say
  • of 8 testers

Specs

Spec Elongated Widebody
Size 16.5 × 7.45 in 15.95 × 8.0 in
Handle 5.8 in, 4.25 in grip 5.6 in, 4.25 in grip
Weight 7.9–8.2 oz listed; 8.0–8.27 oz measured with weights; 7.7–7.84 oz without 7.9–8.2 oz listed; 7.8 oz without weights (Johnkew)
Swingweight 118 ± 2 listed; 122.3 (Matt's Pickleball) 112 ± 2 listed; 117.5 (Johnkew)
Twistweight 6.9 ± 0.2 listed; 6.9 (Matt's Pickleball) 7.9 ± 0.2 listed; 7.95 (Johnkew)
Core 16mm "ReactCore": a foam (PureFoam) floating center, a second PureFoam ring and an EVA power ring Same
Face Multi-layer T700 carbon with InfiniGrit; USA Pickleball approved Same
Weights Two 7.5 g MOI weights that clip on anywhere along the edge guard Same
Warranty Limited lifetime (US), 30-day returns Same
Price $300 on Selkirk's store on November 15, 2026 Same

Listed figures are Selkirk's; measured figures are the testers' own units. Selkirk rates both shapes 9 for power, 10 for spin and 9 for control. The Boomstik cost $333 and has a thicker EVA ring.

Edge and MOI weight detail of the original Selkirk LABS Boomstik
The original LABS Boomstik edge, shown for comparison with the OMNI's adjustable weighting system. This is not an OMNI product photo. Manufacturer photo: Selkirk Sport, used from its media kit.

The 8 testers at a glance

Tester Date Verdict in brief
Pickleball Studio May 29, 2026 Drilling only, because of an injury. With the weights on it's an aggressive, stiff, hollow paddle not much easier to control than the Boomstick; with them off it's softer and he liked it more. A tough sell at $300: he'd buy a Friday Aura or Six Zero Coral Pro.
Pickleball Playbook May 30, 2026 "Way on the power side" of all-court, with a massive sweet spot. Drops needed aiming lower; resets were "a dream". A huge upgrade from the Boomstik for most players.
Matt's Pickleball¹ Jun 1, 2026 After two weeks: a genuine all-court paddle, just above average for power, pop and spin, with an odd "adaptive" feel: soft on touch shots, crisper on drives. Recommended for intermediate-to-advanced players with a developed touch game.
Johnkew Pickleball Jun 2, 2026 Lab tests and eight hours of play: low end of the power category, elite spin when new but mid-table grit durability, and a sweet spot that feels like "a slightly deflated Boomstik". A really good paddle, but he still prefers the Boomstik.
West Side Pickleball Jun 2, 2026 "One of the best all-court paddles I've ever played": more control than the Friday Aura or Six Zero Coral and a sweet spot close to the Boomstik's. Put-aways need more effort. Would buy it at $250; at $300 he'd look around first.
Rackets & Runners¹ Jul 3, 2026 About 90% of the Boomstik's top-end play with more cushioning, still a power paddle on par with the Honolulu CRS. Found the feel a little muted. For players who found the Boomstik too hot, not for control-first players.
Famous by Friday Pickleball Jul 4, 2026 A "plush ride", 52 mph serves and much more accuracy than the Boomstik, which has more power, spin and "wow moments". Would play it over the Boomstik, but $300 is "really pricey".
Nikki Maldonado Aug 11, 2026 A self-described 3.0–4.0 rec player: the paddle "most Boomstik owners should own". Superb serves, drops, dinks and flicks; less scary overheads and a bit short on singles drives. Her number two paddle.

¹ Retailer that sells this paddle. Pickleball Studio, Johnkew and Matt's Pickleball received their paddles from Selkirk. Six of the eight link to discount or gift-card codes; Rackets & Runners links to its own store.

Where the testers agree

Where they disagree: the sweet spot

Rackets & Runners calls it bigger than 99% of paddles and the closest to the Boomstik's; West Side and Famous by Friday also found it large. But three of the four who compared directly found it smaller than the Boomstik's. Johnkew describes the OMNI as "a slightly deflated Boomstik", with more drop-off toward the edges of the elongated, and prefers the widebody for that reason. Pickleball Playbook found it as big as the Boomstik's, or bigger.

Weights on or off?

The testers who tried it without weights disagree, and it depends on the shape:

Tester Without the weights
Pickleball Studio Softer and more all-court; he preferred it this way
Pickleball Playbook Much faster in the hand; he liked it more, though he shanked his first ball of the day
Johnkew Widebody fine; elongated "too unstable" (twistweight fell below 6). Favorite: elongated weights at 8 and 4 o'clock
Matt's Pickleball Elongated "just not playable" for him. Favorite: just above the lower corners
West Side "Almost too light"; he moves them higher for singles

Nikki Maldonado and Rackets & Runners tried the weights higher up and went back to Selkirk's stock position, which is marked on the face.

Build quality: watch the edge guard

Johnkew's widebody edge guard came loose while he was moving a weight higher, and Matt's Pickleball had one side come loose too. Loose edge guards were a known problem on the Boomstik. Pickleball Studio (100 on-off cycles) and West Side (about 50, over 12 hours) had no problems. Selkirk's limited lifetime warranty covers manufacturing defects, and Nikki Maldonado says Selkirk replaced her loose-edged Boomstik quickly.

Worth $300?

Four testers think it's a stretch. Pickleball Studio would spend his own money on the Friday Aura (about $130) or Six Zero Coral Pro; West Side would buy it at $250 but at $300 would look around first; Famous by Friday calls the price its "biggest hindrance"; and Johnkew notes cheaper paddles with similar power and longer-lasting spin. Matt's Pickleball and Nikki Maldonado recommend it at the price, and several testers count Selkirk's warranty and customer service as part of the value.

Only one tester mentioned this

  • Matt's Pickleball: it feels soft on touch shots but firmer on drives, which he links to the layered core.
  • Rackets & Runners: the muted feel made soft spin shots less confident; he hit his drops flatter.
  • Famous by Friday: consistency took time to dial in, as with most foam paddles; he still thinks the SLK ERA Power is Selkirk's best recent paddle.
  • Nikki Maldonado: the handle felt a little long for her small hands.

Who it's for and who should skip it

✅ Consider it if you… ❌ Look elsewhere if you…
Like the Boomstik's feel but find it too hot Want the most power: the Boomstik ST or original Boomstik
Want to tune the paddle's weight without lead tape Want a soft, dense control paddle
Value Selkirk's lifetime warranty Want the best value or the longest-lasting grit

US prices

Retailer Price Usual price Stock
Selkirk $300 $300 In stock

Checked on November 15, 2026 on Selkirk's own store, before tax. Testers note there are no discounts, only gift cards through creator codes. Prices change often.

Watch the reviews

Play video
Selkirk OMNI Review: More Control, But With TradeoffsVideo by Johnkew Pickleball on YouTube

Common questions

What's the difference between the Selkirk OMNI and the Boomstik?

The OMNI is a toned-down Boomstik with less springy foam in the core. All 8 testers found it less powerful, and 7 found the soft game easier.

Is the Selkirk OMNI a control paddle?

No. 6 of 8 testers still call it a powerful paddle; it sits between the Boomstik and a soft control paddle.

Is the Selkirk OMNI worth $300?

4 of 8 testers think $300 is a stretch when cheaper all-court paddles exist.

Are there durability concerns with the OMNI?

2 of 8 testers, Johnkew and Matt's Pickleball, had an edge guard come loose.

Weighing up Selkirk's other paddles? See Selkirk paddles compared: Boomstik ST vs OMNI vs LUXX, plus the SLK ERA.

Sources

Not counted: comparison videos and reviews under four minutes. We found at least eight more OMNI reviews and will add testers when we next update this page.

Some links on this page may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure